The Myth of a Plot-Driven Story

Dear writer,

Something has been on my mind recently that I would really like to discuss.

We are often told there are two types of stories: the plot-driven and the character-driven, and for those of you who are not familiar with the terms, a plot-driven story means the focus is more on the events, actions and twists of the story, rather than in a character-driven story where the focus is more on the character arcs, inner conflict and character development.

But I would argue this and say that, in a sense, all stories are character-driven or character-focused, and if they aren’t, then that would make for an impact-less story.

It is true, especially in the mystery genre, where the characters are focused on solving the crime and piecing together the puzzle, that the plot is a major element of the story. But the misconception that comes with that knowledge is the plot is what makes the readers care for the story. In fact, the plot is never what makes the readers care for the story. What does make the readers care, however, is how the plot affects the characters.

I’m sure you’ve seen game shows on TV where the contestants are playing to win a lot of money. When asked what they would do when they won the money, one person may say they want to buy a car they’ve always wanted, and another person may say they have a sick family member, need this money to pay for medical bills, and they have no other means to pay this expense. So, who would you rather win the money? Your answer would most likely be the person who has a sick family member because you can sympathise with their struggle, and the stakes are high. If they didn’t win, that could mean the worst for their family. So you can understand, even though game shows like this are plot-driven, you are more invested in how it impacts the contestant more than the premise of the show.

This is something to always keep in mind when writing your own story. The plot can be fun, but how it personally impacts the characters is what will make your reader care.

So, in your next writing session, ask yourself: how does this event impact my character? Why does my character care about this event?

Much love,

Elena